In a racist move that could reshape the future of American academia and scientific innovation, the House of Representatives recently passed H.R.1398: Protect America's Innovation and Economic Security from the CCP Act of 2024. Compared to the infamous "Chinese Exclusion Act" of the late 19th century, the newest legislation takes aim at Chinese researchers and academics. It perpetuates a false narrative that wrongly conflates Chinese descent with espionage. Its passage revives discriminatory policies, previously dismantled under the Biden administration, and sets a dangerous precedent.
The "New Chinese Exclusion Act" is more than just another piece of legislation—it is a form of institutionalized racism that has been tailored to perpetuate racial prejudice in the name of national security. H.R.1398 explicitly targets individuals working in science and academia, painting a broad and damaging brushstroke overall of Chinese scholars as potential "spies." This bill feeds into a racially charged narrative that perpetuates a culture of suspicion based on ethnicity rather than evidence.
CODEPINK’s Newsletter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
A History of Racially Motivated Policies
The current legislation is linked to the "China Initiative" launched under the Trump administration. Under "national security," that initiative aimed to uncover Chinese espionage by scrutinizing Chinese nationals, primarily in research and academic institutions. However, its real-world consequences were far more dubious.
The chilling effect of the "China Initiative" resulted in the unjust decline in Asian American researchers being hired in sensitive fields as institutions feared they could be harboring spies. The atmosphere of distrust fragmented workplaces and made academic institutions a battleground for racial prejudice.
The "China Initiative" failed to produce meaningful results despite its impact. Of the over 250 Asian American researchers caught in its racial profiling - only three were ever convicted. The outcome proved that most of the investigations were based on little more than baseless accusations and racial profiling. This track record underscores the inherent flaws in policies that cast suspicion on an entire group of people based solely on their ethnicity.
A New Threat to Asian American Scholars
H.R.1398 builds upon the legacy of the "China Initiative" but with even greater potential for harm. It passed the House by a vote of 237-180, supported overwhelmingly by Republicans, and now awaits further consideration in the Senate. If it becomes law, the bill will give unchecked power to government agencies to scrutinize and investigate Chinese-American researchers under the pretense of protecting U.S. innovation. However, the actual consequence of this policy will not be an increase in national security but rather a perpetuation of xenophobia and racial discrimination.
Members of Congress, particularly from the Asian American and Pacific Islander (AAPI) community, have vocally condemned the bill. Representative Judy Chu described it as a form of "new McCarthyism," a reference to the mid-20th century witch hunts that destroyed countless lives based on unfounded accusations of communist sympathies. Congressman Jerry Nadler warned that the bill would make anyone of Chinese descent in academia a "suspect" in the eyes of the law. This kind of racial profiling is not only unconstitutional but also a violation of the very principles upon which America was founded.
The Personal Toll: Tragedy and Heartbreak
The human cost of these investigations cannot be overstated. One tragic example is the story of Dr. Jane Wu, a prominent neuroscientist at Northwestern University, whose career was derailed by suspicions surrounding her ties to China. Wu, a trailblazer in molecular biology and neurodegenerative diseases, saw her research and lab destroyed after a government investigation tried to link her to the Chinese Communist Party. After being falsely accused, Wu suffered from public scrutiny and professional backlash that led to her heartbreaking suicide in July 2024. Wu's death is a stark reminder of the devastating toll such policies take on real people—people whose careers, lives, and families are shattered by paranoia and prejudice.
Wu's story is far from unique. It is part of a broader pattern of unjust accusations inflicted on the AAPI community by racially motivated policies in the name of national security. These policies send a dangerous message: Asian American researchers are guilty until proven innocent. The consequences are not only professional setbacks but, as in Wu's case, can be deadly.
The Perils of Politicizing Science and Technology
At its core, the New Chinese Exclusion Act is a racist attempt to politicize science and technology. By framing academic and research environments as hotbeds for espionage, the legislation undermines the principles of free inquiry and intellectual exchange that are the foundation of innovation. If passed, it will drive talented scientists and researchers away from the U.S. and deepen the existing racial divides within academic institutions.
Science thrives on diversity—on the exchange of ideas across borders, cultures, and experiences. When academic institutions begin to close their doors to researchers based on race or nationality, they risk stifling the very innovation they seek to protect. The U.S. has long been a leader in scientific discovery because of its ability to attract talent worldwide. However, legislation that targets individuals based on ethnicity will only harm our global standing, creating an environment where collaboration is replaced with suspicion.
A Call for Accountability
Legislators must recognize the long-term consequences of policies like H.R. 1398. This bill does not protect America's innovation—it threatens it. It does not enhance national security—it diminishes the rights and dignity of individuals who have contributed significantly to American society. The bill must be stopped, and policymakers must take a hard look at the damage caused by racial profiling and xenophobia disguised as security measures.
The tragic death of Dr. Jane Wu should serve as a wake-up call for the U.S. government. These agenda-driven investigations extend far beyond the political sphere, costing lives, careers, and human potential. Congress must act in the interest of all Americans, rejecting legislation that discriminates against one group based on race or nationality.
To protect the future of American science and innovation, we must ensure that the policies we create are rooted in fairness and justice—not fear and prejudice. It is time to stop repeating the mistakes of the past and move toward a future where all individuals, regardless of their ethnicity, can contribute to the collective advancement of knowledge without the fear of racial profiling and discrimination.
